cinriter ([info]cinriter) wrote,
@ 2008-06-11 23:02:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Chancy charities
Over at HWA's forum, one big topic of discussion recently has been charity anthologies. Y'know, these are books that solicit stories from authors with the ultimate goal of creating a book that will generate money for a given charity.

Myself, I stayed out of this discussion because I like the idea of helping out a worthy cause, and I have no problem with granting reprint rights to something that I've already made money from. Hey, I know my name's no big deal, but heck - if I tell three people to go buy the book, that's a few more extra dollars for the beneficiary, right? But a lot of HWA's hardline pros have argued against ever giving work to a charity antho, even a reprint.

Okay, so I just got copies of two charity anthologies I gave work to. One, Jack Haringa Must Die!, is extremely well designed and very entertaining; my entry is an honest-to-goodness post that first appeared in this blog. The book benefits the new Shirley Jackson Awards, and I hope they make some extra dough from it. Here's a handy-dandy link for ordering: Jack Haringa Must Die!.

The other one is called Help, and benefits the Preditors & Editors website. I like these guys; I've used them to check on agents, and they've never steered me wrong. Now they're being sued by a couple of shady creepazoids they called out. I wanted to help, so I gave the Help anthology a reprint of a story that I published back in 1999 (it was originally in the Steve Jones anthology White of the Moon).

Now, I don't want to steer people away from Preditors & Editors; please, by all means, go to their website and donate to their legal defense fund. But y'know what? Don't buy this book. It's really embarrassing. Forget the layout that looks as if it was done in a 7-point font in Notepad, forget the cover art that looks like it was blown up from a 100-pixel square piece of art...I could have forgotten that if they hadn't completely screwed up my story "Ego-Alien". All I know is I sent them a Word file with proper formatting in place, and what I see in the book has none of my italics and none of my section breaks; this story was dependent on that formatting, and now it's just been rendered into a huge mass of gibberish.

So, here's my offer: I've created a PDF of "Ego-Alien", one that is properly formatted. If you've purchased Help, please DO NOT read "Ego-Alien" as it is presented in the book. Instead, please click here to download the PDF. If you haven't purchased the Help anthology, please feel free to read "Ego-Alien", and perhaps afterward you'll consider donating a few bucks to Preditors & Editors. Thank you.

And beware who you give reprints to in the future. Sometimes it pays to listen to the old guys at HWA.



(Post a new comment)


[info]nick_kaufmann
2008-06-12 02:44 pm UTC (link)
But a lot of HWA's hardline pros have argued against ever giving work to a charity antho, even a reprint.

I just want to clear up the above sentence, as I think it's a slight mischaracterization of what we've been saying on the HWA board. We've been warning people to be wary of charity anthos because there are so many Tom, Dick and Harrys out there slapping them together as a way to get their own names out there, and in the end the charity anthos wind up not selling anyway because they're POD, not on bookstore shelves, and filled with drecky stories from no-names, since nobody really gets rejected from this kind of charity project.

So yes, wary, but NEVER giving anything to a charity anthology? Hell, if I were asked to submit something top a charity anthology published by Random House and edited by Harlan Ellison, of course I would, because those are the kind of charity anthos that actually get read!

(Though it still stands to reason that direct donations help more than charity anthos do. The sad truth is that a lot of people don't make direct donations because they think they've done enough by submitting something to, or publishing, a charity antho.)

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]nihilistic_kid
2008-06-12 02:56 pm UTC (link)

So yes, wary, but NEVER giving anything to a charity anthology? Hell, if I were asked to submit something top a charity anthology published by Random House and edited by Harlan Ellison, of course I would, because those are the kind of charity anthos that actually get read!


And thus actually make money for the charity, while spreading awareness.

As far as this charity antho, it worked! Nobody is talking about how its co-editor and publisher called Brian Keene and Tim Lebbon "book niggers" anymore, or how he accused Keene of having an affair with another writer. That was the actual goal of the whole anthology.

Edited at 2008-06-12 02:57 pm UTC

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]nick_kaufmann
2008-06-12 02:58 pm UTC (link)
Plus I'm sure his new novel SNUFF sold an extra copy!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]cinriter
2008-06-12 04:33 pm UTC (link)
Thanks for the clarification, Nick. Yep, I've learned my lesson.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


(Anonymous)
2008-06-12 05:53 pm UTC (link)
It's a shame that the layout of the book is so bad as there are some good stories in there (I've only been dipping in and finding it hard to find things with the lack of page numbers on the index list). I was lucky as my story isn't hanging off the end of the page like most (there is actually a whole blank page before and another after it), though I did note the lack of italics.



Cate
http://fright-fest.blogspot.com

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…